Skip to main content

Journalist Creates Fake Business, Easily Buys Yelp Reviews & Social Followers

You've never heard of Freakin' Awesome Karaoke Express? Aww, it's the best mobile karaoke truck in the Bay area!

Freakin' Awesome Karaoke Express truck

The bad news: it's not real.

Freakin' Awesome Karaoke Express (FAKE for short) is the creation of Kashmir Hill, senior editor at Fusion.

You might have seen a review on Yelp that said it's perfect for a girl's night out or a Facebook review that mentioned it being a crowd-pleaser at a neighborhood block party. You may have been impressed by its 19,000 Twitter followers, and considered hiring this mobile song-slinging truck to drive up to your next outdoor shindig.

Kashmir says, "I wanted to see firsthand how the fake reputation economy operates. The investigation led me to an online marketplace where a good reputation comes cheap."

"For $5, I could get 200 Facebook fans, or 6,000 Twitter followers, or I could get @SMExpertsBiz to tweet about the truck to the account's 26,000 Twitter fans. $5 could get me a Facebook review, a Google review, an Amazon review, or, less easily, a Yelp review."

She found all these offers on, a "global online marketplace for creative and professional services."

"When I identified myself as a journalist and sent messages to people offering to write reviews, they said, 'We only do real reviews. We really try the products. People send them to us.' But when I approached them undercover with money in hand, it was a different matter."

Fusion's art department came up with a logo and a photoshop composite of a super party truck. Armed with that, a new Gmail account and a burner phone number, she created a Yelp profile, a Facebook page, a Twitter account, and a page on Launchrock - a start-up that encourages you to make a website before your product is real to gauge interest for it. She set up Google Analytics so she could seen when someone from Yelp visited the Launchrock page before she let the Yelp profile go live.

Yelp review page for Freakin' Awesome Karaoke Express

Since the story has come out, the paid reviews have been filtered, but you can see them here:

paid Yelp reviews

Kashmir interviewed a woman who wrote a fake Yelp review:

I eventually came clean with her, and told her that I had hired her undercover and that she had written a completely fake review for my karaoke truck. She was silent for a while and then told me she thought it was real because it had a website. She said she's sympathetic to new businesses that need reviews to get first-time customers through the door.

"I don't mind helping out a new business or a business that doesn't have much of an internet reputation, even if I haven't been there before," she said. "Plus, businesses need positive reviews sometimes, because people are more likely to leave a negative review than a positive one."

"Everyone online needs to use their best judgment," she said. "Just because a product has good reviews doesn't mean it's good. You can't believe everything you read online."

Kashmir's story appears here: "I created a fake business and bought it an amazing online reputation"

Important: Although this story is eye-opening and humorous, we must warn that buying Yelp reviews can have terrible consequences for your Yelp business page. Yelp will not only filter reviews, but publicly shame you.

Handle Complaints Privately, in Real-Time

Get Anonymous Customer Feedback by Text Message

Our service allows your customers to send you anonymous feedback by text message, but you can still text them back and resolve problems before the customer leaves. It's completely private.

First month FREE. Then only $29 per month per location.
No contracts. No setup fees. Cancel online anytime.

Jamila Thompson

With 10 years in the restaurant industry and 7 years as a cook/chef, I have a passion for helping restaurant owners succeed and create wonderful experiences for their guests. Food is love.

comments powered by Disqus