Skip to main content

5 Big Problems with Comment Cards

Comment Card

Comment cards are a common tool for getting customers to tell you what’s on their mind, but they’re far from perfect. There are a few ways to improve them, but not all issues can be solved by using comment cards alone.

1. They Don’t Fix The Problem for This Customer

What comment cards do is allow you to discover problems to fix, whether the problem is with the facility (cleanliness, comfort), service (wait times, staff politeness), or product (food quality [restaurant, hotel], accommodation [hotel]).  Once fixed, future patrons will have a better experience.  But for the customer that wrote it, and perhaps all other patrons in the establishment at the same time, the experience and first impression were flawed. It’s too late for them.

In short, comment cards fix the future, not the present.

2. They Are Often Out of Sight

If your comment cards are in a kiosk next to the salad bar, condiment stand, or hostess station, it’s most likely your customer won’t see them, and therefore won’t use them.  Out of sight, out of mind means that the customer will leave, taking their opinions with them, and off to Yelp, Facebook or wherever they prefer to complain.  The real insult is if they are sitting in your establishment writing that bad review from their smartphone.

3. Every Step To Completing a Card Will Lead to Fewer Submissions

At each step in filling out a card, people will fail to go to the next step. So for each step or hindrance along the way will result in a severe drop-off in numbers of cards you will receive.

Here are few spots along the process where customers will just give up:

  1. Finding the card. If it’s not on the table or in the guest check, it will likely be missed.
  2. Have a pen? Most men don’t carry pens with them.
  3. Length of card. The longer the card and more involved it is, the less likely you’ll ever get it.
  4. Suggesting the customer enter their name and/or address. It’s not hard to do, but it’s more work. And some folks will not give you their address because either they want to be anonymous or they are afraid you’ll send them junk mail.
  5. Requiring the customer to mail it. The comment card pictured at the top of this post required the customer to place a stamp on it and mail it. What? Why not let the customer use business reply mail, and save them a stamp?

4. Not Allowing the Customer to Be Anonymous Will Lead to Fewer Responses

Like I mentioned above, some folks will not give you their address because either they want to be anonymous or they are afraid you’ll send them junk mail.  Requiring their name and address will lead to the customer scrapping the card.

5. Anonymous Comments Don’t Let You Contact the Customer to Fix The Issue

If the customer is anonymous, you have no way to respond and assure them you will fix the situation, therefore no way to fix the relationship with that customer.

A Better Way

You can dump comment cards and use our awesome solution, which actually makes commenting fun, quick and easy, as well as anonymous (but with the ability to respond).

We've helped hundreds of businesses just like yours improve their operations, save money, and improve their relationship with customers.

We invite you to take a look at TalkToTheManager, the easiest way to get real-time, honest (and anonymous) customer feedback. You can reply to customers immediately and address any issues before customers leave. We help you make sure that every customer leaves happy.

comments powered by Disqus